Speakers
Description
A beverage stabilization platform closes its attitude loop over FDCAN and reads a fused inertial measurement unit. Controller comparisons can confound structure with tuning and the robustness margin each design accepts. We constrain PID, RST, LQR, LQG and MRAC to an identical nominal peak sensitivity, leaving bandwidth free. Hardware identification uses swept-amplitude square waves, cross-validation and frequency-response screening. Simulation then includes the identified delay, conservative sensor noise and command limits. The 62.5 ms delay spans the bus round trip, drive loops and sensor fusion; control arithmetic is estimated at 0.1 µs. At matched peak sensitivity, pitch bandwidth spans a factor of 3.3. PID leads one of twelve cases and trails the case-best composite score by up to 66%. The constant-numerator model permits state reconstruction from measured and stored signals; estimator-free LQR achieves 35–37% more bandwidth than LQG. MRAC wins none of the twelve composite comparisons. The open-source toolchain reproduces identification, synthesis and simulation; the predicted controller ordering still requires hardware validation.